Home | Contact Us | Sitemap | This Week’s News | Avrosport - The Archive | Links | England | The World Cup | Arsenal | Aston Villa | Birmingham City | Blackburn Rovers | Bolton Wanderers | Charlton Athletic | Chelsea Everton Fulham | Liverpool | Manchester City | Manchester United |  Middlesbrough | Newcastle United | Portsmouth | Reading | Shefield United | Sunderland | Southampton | Tottenham Hotspur | Watford | West Ham United | West Bromwich Albion | Wolverhampton Wanderers | The Media | Hot Topics | Referees

 

 

This Weeks News

Hot Topics

Everything Under Control

FA Justice in Action

Three for Sorrow


England

Alan Ball


Arsenal

Did Arsene Get His Sums Wrong?

Arsenal Star Milton Dies

Soho Square Farce

Ashley and a Heavy Dose of the Blues

Arsenal and the Future

Clean Sweep for Arsenal


Blackburn Rovers

Blackburn's European Ambitions Dented


Bolton Wanderers

Bolton Wise, Pound Foolish

Downsizing at Bolton


Chelsea

It's Thumbs Up for Lampard

How Chelsea Blew it in Geordieland

Another Fine Mess, Mourinho

Chelsea's Big Mistake

Sideways is Best for Chelsea

Chelsea on the Slide

Chelsea - Play or Pose?

Striker Light

Chelsea Fail Again

All Quiet in the Chelsea Midfield

The Price of Failure

Power Cut

Chelsea Lose Their Title

No Fear


Liverpool

The Nation Backs Liverpool

Liverpool Make it Big

Liverpool Should Be Cautious


Manchester City

Manchester Teams Worlds Apart


Manchester United

United Narrow Favourites

The Art of Being Bullish

Alex Gets Arsene's Vote

Crying in the Rain

Champions United Make Their Point


Newcastle United

Glenn Roeder


Portsmouth

Record for Portsmouth Keeper

Your Round, Harry


Tottenham Hotspur

Tottenham, Envy and the Price of Silver

Arsenal Expose Underachieving Spurs

Tottenham Hotspur - You Have to Laugh


Referees

Straw Poll





 

Marks and Sparks


Don’t you just love picking up the papers after a big match, checking out the marks out of ten (why is it always ‘out of ten’?) awarded to the players and wondering whether the journalist in question was actually at the game.

To begin with, there is a sort of unwritten rule that the generosity of the awards is dictated by the result. A good win ensures that everyone gets high marks, a bad defeat means poor marks all round, with appropriate (and sometimes inappropriate) rankings for any game in between.

Take the News of the World for instance. Naturally, all the England players were rated highly for their contribution to the memorable victory against Argentina – but some of the individual decisions by reporter David Harrison were surprising to say the least.

No problem with a 9 for Paul Robinson’s outstanding display in goal, or Wayne Rooney’s terrific contribution all over the place. But considerable difficulty in accepting that, at just one mark less, we are invited to consider the performances of Luke Young, Rio Ferdinand, John Terry and Frank Lampard to be almost as good.

When you read the comments that accompany these over-generous 8s, it becomes even more puzzling. Luke Young’s tackling “can be reckless and he earned himself a yellow card for a wild lunge”. Rio “Still looks out of sorts with lapses of concentration and misjudgement becoming a worry. He failed to cut out the cross for Crespo’s opening goal and was often troubled by Argies movement. Will have to sharpen up his game considerably.” John Terry “was also caused problems by the mobility of the opponents.” Lampard gave “a more subdued performance”, his “passing wasn’t always accurate”, he “gave the ball away far too often” and “blasted a couple of shots off target.”

How can anyone get that much wrong and earn 8 out of 10? How can Robinson and Rooney be so much better and only be awarded 9? How can David Beckham’s committed, controlled and technically accomplished performance, including a tremendous glancing header to set up Wayne Rooney’s goal, merit only an 8, while Steven Gerrard is apparently worth 9 for a moderate display whose highlights were a terrific first half shot and a wonderful cross for Owen’s equalizer?

Incidentally, Owen’s “quiet display” rated 9 – no doubt because he scored two. And that’s a whole lot more than David Harrison’s marking merits.